|
I’m
generally pretty bored with films that are described as
“coming of age” pictures.
Words like “moving,” “touching,” and
“emotional” are usually thrown in for good measure, and each
seems like a red flag for both sappy content and predictable,
linear stories.
Thankfully,
José Luis Cuerda’s The Butterfly is still an
exceptionally enjoyable film, despite being all of the things
listed above. The film is about the relationship between a young boy and
his teacher, and it's set in mid-‘30s Spain during the
country’s transition from a monarchy to a republic.
Moncho
(Manuel Lozano, in his film debut) is a young boy who has been
taught at home by his tailor father Ramón (Gonzalo M. Uriarte)
because he’s asthmatic. On
the eve of his first day of public school, Moncho’s older
brother Andrés (Alexis de los Santos, also in his debut)
horrifies the young boy with tales of the beatings he's taken
from his teachers over the years.
So it's no surprise when Moncho pisses his pants the
following morning, just because his old, craggy teacher, Don
Gregorio (Fernando Fernán Gómez, The Grandfather),
asked him what his name was.
Of
course, Don Gregorio turns out to be a really nice guy.
He and Moncho form a special bond (but not like the usual
kind between priests and young boys, or even Boy Scout leaders
and young boys), and both share an interest in nature.
At first I was worried, because the last old Don that
hung around outside this much keeled over in a tomato garden
with an orange in his mouth.
But nothing like that happens here.
Don Gregorio is an old softie and appears to be the first
hippie teacher - a precursor to the tie-dyed David van Dreesen
from Beavis & Butt-Head.
The
rest of The Butterfly is rife with the undercurrent of
Spain’s political upheaval, and there are subplots involving
Andrés’ invitation to play the saxophone with a touring band
and the town whore. The film is actually based on three short stories written by
Manuel Rivas in "Que Me Quieres, Amor” and was adapted by
Rafael Azcona.
In
addition to being beautifully photographed by Javier G. Salmones
(Twice Upon A Yesterday), The Butterfly features
terrific performances by the young first-timer Uriarte and the
rubber-faced Gómez, the latter of whom could pass himself off
as the Spanish Walter Matthau. Directed by José Luis Cuerda, The Butterfly was
nominated for thirteen Goya Awards (the Spanish equivalent of
the Oscar). It only
took home one trophy (for Best Screenplay) but would have swept
everything if it weren’t for a little film called All About
My Mother.
Previously
titled The Butterfly’s Tongue (taken from the Spanish
title La Lengua de las Mariposas), The Butterfly
might seem like something you may want to expose your kids to,
what with the cool combination of uplifting story and political
education. But
parents, beware: The film has a pretty graphic sex scene,
features perky schoolgirls swimming without tops and, for good
measure, even throws in a scene where a dog is cooked on a spit.
I screened the film as part of the Cleveland
International Film Festival and saw some poor mother ushering
her kid out of the theatre during all of the parts that could
permanently scar the impressionable brain of her child.
She must have been pretty tired when the credits finally
rolled.
1:35
-
for nudity and strong sexual content
|