|
Himalaya
sounds a lot like something you'd find at your local IMAX
theatre. For
starters, it's full of stunning panoramic shots that can't help
but overshadow an inferior plot.
The film tells the story of a young boy (kids are an IMAX
staple) on track to become Chief of his Nepalese village, which
means audiences will be treated to magnificent views of
snow-covered mountains that practically dare people to cross
them.
Anyone
familiar with Iranian cinema will notice similarities between Himalaya
(an awfully fun word to type) and that country's recent critical
hit A Time For Drunken Horses
– this could have been called A Time For Teetotaling Yaks.
Both films deal with impoverished villages whose survival
depends on caravans that wind through the dangerous mountains.
While Horses' characters
smuggled contraband into Iraq, the people in Himalaya
haul packs of salt hundreds of miles away to exchange for grain
that will keep their tribes eating throughout the harsh winter
months.
As
Himalaya opens, the salt caravan has just returned to
town. One might think this would be a time for celebration, like
when the fishing boats came home to Gloucester at the beginning
of The Perfect Storm, but
this time the convoy has returned with the remains of their
Chief in a burlap sack. Lhakpa, we are told by his close friend
and caravaneer Karma (Gurgon Kyap), died trying to follow a
risky path. Lhakpa's elderly father Tinle (Thilen Lhondup) doesn't
believe Karma, suspecting he may have done something devious to
assume his place in the community.
A
power struggle ensues, with most of the villagers in favor of
Karma taking over, but Tinle thinks the gig should remain in his
lineage (he was the Chief before Lhakpa).
The only problem is that the family's next male heir is
little boy named Tsering (Karma Wangel), who isn't nearly ready
to man a salt caravan through mountains big enough to make Lance
Armstrong burst into tears.
But
that's not enough to stop crotchety old Tinle, who comes off as
a taller, Far East version of Cotton from King of the Hill
(he even has a few "I've been blah-blah-blah-ing since
before you were born!" lines).
Tinle hauls his other son, Norbou (Karma Tensing), out of
the monastery he was forced into as a boy and starts his own
damn caravan (another fun word to type) with a few of the
village elders, his grandson and his widowed daughter-in-law (Lhakpa
Tsamchoe).
What
follows is probably the closest thing we'll ever see to a
Nepalese road-trip flick, as the two separate caravans (Karma's
and Tinle's) embark on the salt-for-grain journey. There's one
dicey scene where Tinle's crew tries to cross a very narrow
mountain path, but filming it was probably a hundred times more
precarious than it appeared on screen.
Not only are there no stunt doubles in Himalaya,
there aren't any professional actors, either.
The faces weathered by the elements that you see on the
screen really have to lug salt through the mountains to exchange
for grain.
Some
folks might complain about the lack of character development,
but since Himalaya is populated by non-actors, beefing up
their parts isn't going to be a positive thing.
It'd be one thing if the picture starred Brad, Julia,
Haley Joel and Robert (as in Redford – his craggy puss would
have been perfect), but the story here is kept pleasantly
simple. It's almost
a fable - old customs (like using astronomy to tell you when to
start the caravan) butting heads with modern thinking (like
using medicine over hocus-pocus stuff).
But not too modern, mind you.
The only major problem with Himalaya is that there
isn't supposed to be a clear-cut protagonist, yet it's hard not
to root for Karma over the gratingly unpleasant Tinle.
Himalaya,
which won César Awards for its score (Bruno Coulais) and
cinematography (Eric Guichard), was Nepal's first-ever
submission to the Academy Awards Best Foreign Language Film
category in 1999 (it was actually nominated, too, but lost to
Spain's All About My Mother).
The picture was directed by Eric Valli, a National
Geographic photographer who, for the last 20 years, has
lived in the same remote Dolpo region of Nepal in which Himalaya
is set (he was also a unit director for Seven Years in Tibet).
The uncomplicated screenplay took four writers to tackle
(one of whom, ironically, was a scribe on fellow 1999 Foreign
Film nominee East-West).
| 1:40
– |
|
 |
|