The Quiet
– Over the last several years, Jamie Babbit has quietly
assembled some of the most brutally honest and campily
hysterical portrayals of dysfunctional suburbia, burgeoning teen
sexuality, and high school life with an emphasis on cheerleaders
and popularity. Her work on the woefully short-lived
television show Popular, and cult hit But
I'm a Cheerleader left me eager for more, and I got it
with The Quiet. Only with less of the camp, since
this film plays way more straight and much more serious than I
was expecting.
Dot (The
Ballad of Jack & Rose's Camilla Belle) is a deaf
mute sent to live with her godmother (Edie Falco) after her
father dies. In addition to her handicapabilities, Dot
also has to deal with a wicked cheerleading stepsister (Elisha
Cuthbert) and a stepdad (Martin Donovan) with some pretty messed
up ideals about what a perfect family represents. And
people talking about her like she's not there. And nobody,
other than a lunch lady, knowing sign language. I could go
on, but I won't.
There's nothing new or groundbreaking here in terms of
content, but as usual, Babbit (she's also directed PSB-recommended
television shows like Gilmore Girls, Malcolm in the
Middle, and the hastily-canceled Wonderfalls) puts it
all together really nicely.
The Notorious Bettie Page
– For some reason, Gretchen Mol (The
Shape of Things) was the last person I thought of when I
heard Mary Harron (American
Psycho) was making a biopic about "the girl with
the perfect figure." Didn't think she had the goods,
so to speak. But the two women pull off a rare
accomplishment: Making a biopic that is neither overly long (see
Ray)
nor slave to a paint-by-numbers format (see Ray).
The majority of the film is in black-and-white, for Pete's sake.
Okay, there are some other issues, like rewriting history
about Page's Congressional smut trial testimony, and the story
about the destruction of the bulk of Page's photographs and
negatives, taken by the legendary Irving "the Pin-Up
King" Klaw. And the fact that the film just kind of
ends, but that's part of the formula-breaking thing, so I'll
keep quiet about it. Mol is terrific, looking like a cross
between Rachel Weisz and Jennifer Tilly, and the supporting cast
(Lily Taylor, Jared Harris, David Strathairn) is a lot of fun,
too. And you learn a ton about Bettie, from her life in
1930's Nashville through her rocket to fame after a move to New
York City in 1949. Harron uses a lot of period stock
footage that seamlessly fit into her picture.
Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull
Story – It's difficult to concisely describe what
the latest from Michael Winterbottom (9
Songs) is about. What you see on the screen
is essentially Winterbottom's mockumentary about the fictitious
shooting of a film adaptation of an unfilmable 18th century
novel called The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy,
Gentleman. We're treated to both the behind-the-scenes
goings on behind the camera, as well as finished footage from
the picture.
Steve Coogan is the star of both Winterbottom's movie, as
well as the fake one contained therein (which is directed by
Jeremy Northam), and his performance made me laugh more than any
other at this festival, save Sarah
Silverman. He's never read the book, which
tells the non-sequential story of his character's conception,
birth and unfortunate naming, mostly because he's too busy
flirting with his assistant (Naomie Harris) without his
girlfriend (Kelly Macdonald) finding out. Also, there's
the battle over the film's financing, script, last-second
casting decisions, as well as a reporter (played by actual New
York Times writer Stephen Rodrick) who will run a story
about Coogan's debaucheries unless he is granted a lengthy
interview, and a constant battle with the costume department
over his heel size so he can remain taller than co-star Rob
Brydon.
This is really funny stuff, especially if you're into British
humor, or appreciate lots of inside jokes about the filmmaking
process.
Bee Season – Oakland
is the setting for the third film from the directing team of
Scott McGehee and David Siegel (The
Deep End). Truthfully, this picture might have
blown me away if its driving force wasn't rooted in the
mysterious secrets of Kabbalah, which instead, made me feel like
I was being brainwashed with some kind of cult recruitment film
(especially since Naomi Fuller's adaptation of Myla Goldberg's
novel pretty much mocks at least two other major
religions). At the end, I knew something horrible or
something magical was going to happen, but instead, I got
something that looked like a Fruitopia commercial.
Richard Gere and Juliette Binoche might be the big names in Season,
but the star is their screen daughter, newcomer Flora Cross, who
plays Eliza Naumann, a sixth-grader who is the youngest of two
children in a dizzily happy Jewish family. Eliza begins to
work her way through local levels of the Scripps Howard National
Spelling Bee (see Spellbound).
The further she gets, the more whacked out her family starts to
act. Mom (Binoche) breaks into houses to steal shiny
trinkets from strangers. Big brother Aaron (Max Minghella)
abandons Judaism when he meets a super-cute Hare Krishna
disciple (Kate Bosworth). And Dad (Gere) becomes convinced
the odd fugue states Eliza enters when she's spelling a word is
some type of mystical ability described in his doctorate thesis
on the Kabbalah. And I thought I had things rough when I
was in the sixth grade . . .
Season was made with care, but little warmth.
This was okay for the tone of The Deep End, but it just
doesn't fit here. It's by no means a bad film,
though. If you can block out the Kabbalah junk, maybe
you'll be able to enjoy it more than I did.
Where the Truth Lies – It's
hard to tell what will alienate audiences more: The multiple
narratives, the multiple time settings, the NC-17 rating, the
mockery of Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis, or the Where the
Truth Lies' last 20 minutes, which offers more twists and
turns than your lower intestines (after a certain number of
jukes, you'll just stop caring).
Atom Egoyan (Ararat) directs
and adapts (from the Rupert Holmes novel) this story about a
'50s nightclub duo who had the world in the palm of their hands
before suddenly and unexpectedly breaking up right after a
wildly successful 1957 Veteran's Day Telethon to raise money for
sick children. The bulk of Lies' action takes place
15 years later, where crack reporter Karen O'Connor (Alison
Lohman) is trying to uncover the truth about a dead hotel
employee (Rachel Blanchard) discovered in the posh suite of
"straight-man" Vince Collins (Colin Firth) and
"wacky Jew" Lanny Morris (Kevin Bacon) after the
aforementioned three-day telethon. The more Karen digs,
the more surprises she uncovers. I think the biggest
surprise is that Lohman was playing Nicolas Cage's daughter here
at the Festival two years ago (Matchstick Men), and here
she gets slammed by Bacon and has a girl/girl scene this year.
The ending is such a strange cliché, most of the folks on
the way out of my press/industry screening were openly mocking
it on the way out. You don't encounter that too often
here, since most viewers at these screenings are too scared to
talk about a film's merits without conferring with a small pack
of colleagues first.
These five films were all screened before 7:00 PM (whew!)
which left me time to take in the Red Sox/Blue Jays game, in
which Big Papi Ortiz slammed two home runs. The first
sailed right into my section. Die Yankees!